Siri Who Am I Review

Siri, Who Am I? Review | Sam Tschida

Today’s review is on Siri, Who Am I? by Sam Tschida. It’s an interesting premise exploring the idea that technology might know more about our identities than we do, but there were elements (the characterisations, for starters) that meant it didn’t entirely work for me. See what you think!

Publisher: Quirke | Date: 2020 | Genre: General Fiction

Plot: Mia might look like a Millennial but she was born yesterday. Emerging from a coma with short-term amnesia after an accident, Mia can’t remember her own name until the Siri assistant on her iPhone provides it. Based on her cool hairstyle (undercut with glamorous waves), dress (Prada), and signature lipstick (Chanel), she senses she’s wealthy, but the only way to know for sure is to retrace her steps once she leaves the hospital. Using Instagram and Uber, she arrives at the pink duplex she calls home in posts but finds Max, a cute, off-duty postdoc supplementing his income with a house-sitting gig. He tells her the house belongs to JP, a billionaire with a chocolate empire. A few texts later, JP confirms her wildest dreams: they’re in love, Mia is living the good life, and he’ll be back that weekend.

But as Mia and Max work backward through her Instagram and across Los Angeles to learn more about her, they discover a surprising truth behind her perfect Instagram feed, and evidence that her head wound was no accident. Who was Mia before she woke up in that hospital? And is it too late for her to rewrite her story?

I received Siri, Who Am I? from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Siri who am I by Sam Tschida

Siri, Who Am I? Review

It’s fair to say not a lot of my reading is set in today’s reality. In my continuing attempt to branch out with different genres, I figured Siri, Who Am I? couldn’t get more up-to-date.

I’m not sure what I was hoping for: someone having the chance to start over, to discover something about themselves that helps them be a better person?

I suppose that’s kind of what I got. But I couldn’t get into this one. I’ll get to the plot but the main issue for me was the characterisations.

Characters

Mia is shallow, self-centred and selfish. She doesn’t think about others, apart from how they can get her what she needs. She’s presumptuous and assumes she has it all. You could say her heart is in the right place, but it’s hard to connect and empathise with her. Despite her phone-book being empty – including not having her own mother’s number – Mia assumes that she is loved, famous and successful, with no evidence to support that.

But while Mia goes on her mission of self-discovery, other characters let it happen. A house-sitter lets her stay there with no proof she has any right to be at the house. They drive around in the owner’s Ferrari and neither of them have a glimmer of a guilty conscious about it. There’s also the hospital staff who let an amnesic patient walk out with staples in her head and no follow up appointment booked.

I wouldn’t want to make any of these artists jealous, but I think I’m struggling more with self-representation than they are at the moment. Being a spectator to my shitty existence is causing way more pain than the guy who painted himself in glasses and hung it on the wall.

Siri, Who Am I? by Sam Tschida

The owner – and Mia’s lover – lets her have whatever she wants, even when she is throwing it all back in his face. Random people she meets are prepared to give up phone numbers and confidential information about others because Mia asks – even when finding her in places she shouldn’t be.

The only character that felt real was the police detective, who isn’t above telling Mia she is in trouble and that memory loss isn’t an excuse to get out of it.

Plot/Writing

The shallowness of the characters is reflected in the plot. It’s superficial from the start: Mia’s release from hospital sets the scene for how things are going to conveniently work in her favour despite the implausibility. I have no idea if the memory loss information is accurate, but given how other events fall into place for Mia, I doubt it. There’s no challenge; no struggle; no sense of Mia attempting to better herself, despite it being the perfect set-up for a feel-good story.

There are several moments where the font changes with Mia’s interaction through either texts or online. While this is how she relates to her reality, as a reader, I found it jarred and further isolated me from the plot.

Final Thoughts

It was a light read with potential: a modern setting with technology as an aid to discovering identity. The plot might have worked even if you cared about the characters, but Mia’s self-centredness meant you didn’t want her to find the answers: she didn’t deserve them.

A disappointing read – maybe I should stick with other worlds!

Does this sound like your kind of book? Have you read it?

You may also like:

Siri Who Am I review - pin it

Twitter | Facebook | Pinterest | Instagram 

57 thoughts on “Siri, Who Am I? Review | Sam Tschida

  1. Oh nooo I was super excited when I read the overall plot at the beginning of this post, but now I feel quite disappointed that it wasn’t as good as it sounded at first. I’m really thankful that you gave your honest review… I’m tempted to give this a read anyway as I love fiction books, but I’ll think about it! Thanks so much for your review.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thanks for your honest review! I’m a sucker for a good book cover (and anything with millennial colours) so I would have fallen for this book immediately! I might see if it’s available on my book app, so I can read for free (well, within my subscription)

    Toni x

    Liked by 1 person

  3. That blurb sounded so promising too! What a let down! That MC self-absorbed nonsense reminds me of Roxy from The Roxy Letters ?. I hope your next book is more fulfilling ❤️

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I thought this was going to be a good from the sound of the plot, but it seems there may be some flaws. It’s great that you explained exactly what you thought and why. Thanks for shrug your review.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I ended up DNFing this one, largely because of the issues you point out. Mia’s assumptions about who she is and what she’s entitled to seemed bizarre and egostistical, and I had a hard time accepting any of the plot developments.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. That’s a bummer! The synopsis sounded quite good, but now that you’ve portrayed Mia like this, I don’t think I fancy reading it anymore! Thanks so much for the heads up!!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Great review! Sorry it was a disappointing read. After reading your review, I don’t think I’ll be reading this any time soon. Either way, I hope you enjoy your next read!

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I am so glad that you were able to read this book and review it but I am sad that you weren’t able to enjoy it. Thank you for reviewing it so it helps to prevent others from going into a book reading slump. I hope you have a great day!

    Like

  9. I was so intrigued by this book but your review made me have second thoughts. But who knows, I might love it..

    Like

  10. I do read books set in this day but it’s never usually set around the social media aspect of it. That’s disappointing that it wasn’t the best read. The characters definitely don’t sounds grest! Loved the review x

    Like

  11. I’m like a lot of people thinking that this plot sounded great, but it’s a shame that the overall thing doesn’t live up to it!

    Daisy xoxo

    Like

  12. Great review! It’s a shame that this was a disappointing read for you because the synopsis sounds so interesting and the perfect lighter read, I hate when the plot sounds so good but the execution is poor so it just ends up ruining the whole book. I read a book / series ages ago called Skinned by Robin Wasserman and it has a similar vibe but this one has more sci fi / futuristic elements, I remember it being quite good, maybe you’d like that one more! Thanks for sharing x

    Like

  13. Such a shame you didn’t enjoy it much, but your review was really interesting to read!

    Like

  14. This is such a shame, it sounded like it had so much potential and could teach us a few things about modern life, a hidden message about only sharing a highlight reel on social media or something like that. It’s disappointing that Mia was so unlikable, it was sounding like a perfect light/ holiday (lol not like that’s happening) read from the synopsis x

    Sophie

    Like

  15. Ah it’s such a shame it didn’t work for you, because the premise sounds so intriguing! But for me, the character’s need to be believable/authentic and they’re what make or break a book.

    Evie x | http://www.eviejayne.co.uk

    Like

  16. Sounds similar to some romantic comedies I saw. I thought it was so interesting that she relied on technology to help her locate her identity. It shows how much stake and how much we rely on technology.

    Like

  17. This book sounded so unique and intriguing from the blurb – it’s a shame you didn’t enjoy it.

    Like

  18. Oh no! After reading the summary, I was quite excited about this book but after reading your review it doesn’t sound as good as it could have been. I was hoping for something that maybe taught us something about modern life or social media. What a shame. Thank you for posting an honest review!

    Like

  19. Wow, the blurb for this sounds so good with a fresh plot. But I can see your disappointment in the book and thought your reasons were very fair. Having felt the same way about a book I recently finished, I think I’ll give this one a miss. Great review though, thanks for sharing! x

    Liked by 1 person

    • You never know, it might work for you, but personally it just wound me up the entire time which was a real shame. I hope your next read is good!

      Like

  20. Love the honest review, the plot sounds like it had potential, but if you can’t connect with the character, then it’s always destined to fail.

    Adam

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s